Unjust Weather

Weather events are often accompanied by injustice. Yesterday, J.B. wrote about the terrible Johnstown Flood. The tragedy occurred when the dam at the South Fork Hunting and Fishing Club above the industrial town of Johnstown, Pennsylvania game way after an extended period of heavy rains on May 31, 1889. A wall of water 75 feet tall rushed down the Little Conemuagh River before warnings could reach the town. South Fork was owned by prominent industrialists from Pittsburgh, including Andrew Carnegie, Henry Clay Frick and Andrew Mellon. A total of 2,200 people died in the disaster. After the tragedy, a lawsuit was filed claiming that the dam was improperly maintained. The suit was thrown out on the basis that the dam break was an act of God. The victims received no compensation.

An even greater injustice has occurred in the hurricane zone of the Gulf Coast. I am reading Douglas Brinkley’s tome about Hurricane Katrina: The Great Deluge. I am appalled at the actions of people in all levels of government. From the highest levels of the government down to cowardly New Orleans Policemen. Don’t get me wrong, there were lots of heroes at all levels also, although more at the lower levels.

The more I read, the more I develop a Hurricane Katrina Hall of Shame...from reporters who prematurely told the nation that the Big Easy had dodged a bullet...to New Orleans policemen who took their police cars or “borrowed“ new Cadillac automobiles as they fled to Houston...to the Corps of Engineers who did not properly engineer the flood walls...to the shipping industry who insisted on the Mississippi River Gulf Outlet which turned into a speedway for the thirty foot storm surge to swamp New Orleans East...to researchers who did not accurately identify and act on the myriad of threats to the flood defenses...to Secretary of State Condoleeza Rice, who attended Spamalot as the Big Easy drowned...o Michael Chertoff, who flew to Atlanta for a flu seminar on Tuesday after the storm...to Kathleen Blanco and President Bush, who were less than stellar in their leadership display.

But the kings of the confederacy of dunces...Michael Brown and Mayor Ray Nagin. A Wednesday email (two days after the hurricane made landfall) from one of Brown's aides told FEMA team members that the FEMA Chief was not getting enough time for dinner, since traffic in baton Rouge was horrible and the restaurants were packed. All the while, less than 500 national guardsmen were maintaining an uneasy and dangerous peace at the Superdome. Finally, Ray Nagin. It took until Saturday night for “that hurricane dude” Max Mayfield to get through to Nagin. (The Mayor spent Saturday night out eating with his family. He was conspicuously absent from the Superdome and City Hall in the days following the storm.

And the people of New Orleans just re-elected him. Go figure!

As Brinkley so aptly put it...Katrina was not a natural disaster, but rather a man made one...
Posted by  
on June 1, 2006, 1:51 am
Stick to the weather, and leave the politics to the politicians.

Reply to this comment
Posted by  
on June 1, 2006, 2:39 am
I can't believe they re-elected him! A very dear friend of mine in New Orleans (she and her family just first got a trailer from FEMA two weeks ago) cried when the results were announced. It's amazing how badly it was handled.

Reply to this comment
Posted by New Mike  
on June 1, 2006, 6:19 am
Way to be on the sideline there Greg..

Reply to this comment
Posted by  
on June 1, 2006, 6:26 am
There wasn't much choice. His opponent was even worse. :(

Reply to this comment
Posted by  
on June 1, 2006, 8:18 am
Thans for the reminder that weather events don't happen in isolation. They are a part of a huge web of events and circumstances. We may not be able to change the weather, but we can take steps to change how it affects us, and how we respond to it.

Reply to this comment
Posted by  
on June 1, 2006, 8:29 am
That was a pretty scathing editorial there. I, for one, appreciate the honesty. There was lots of fault to spread around, but the underlying problem was a combination of natural disaster and a national disaster. The hurricane was the natural disaster; the people's dependency on government to provide for them, and an unwillingness to get off their butts and do the right thing was was the national disaster, still in process. Blame is a problem with certain groups in the country. Thank you for your relections on a problem that is still accelerating.

Reply to this comment
Posted by   www
on June 1, 2006, 8:54 am
I totally agree with Ashley, a natural disaster of historic proportion with a lacking of leadership at all levels of equal portions. My personal take however, lays the largest blame at the feet of the Mayor. Action climbs the ladder not descends, I only hope is since they've reelected the same leadership is they don't complain or expect large scale help the next time, but that's empty hope I know..sad situation all around.

PS..Greg its a blog, it's a place for opinons, its the internet, its open for reasonable discussion.

Reply to this comment
Posted by Chris  
on June 1, 2006, 12:46 pm
For all the failure at different levels of leadership, I can't imagine that any other potential president (be it Kerry, Gore, McCain (of 2000, lest we forget his 2005 birthday party), Clinton) would have been so laissez-faire with regard to the unfolding tragedy. In cases such as this, leaders need to take full account of what happened in order that it doesn't happen again -- forget blame, there has been no accountability for the failures of the systems we supposedly have in place for just such occasions. The president doesn't seem to care...

Reply to this comment
Posted by  
on June 1, 2006, 1:01 pm
The failure to build adequate levees was the root of the problem. They were never capable of handling anything worse than a Cat 3, and everyone knew it was just a matter of time until something worse came along. If the Chinese could build a wall thousands of miles long, centuries ago, why couldn't we have put up a concrete levee able to withstand a Cat 5 hurricane. Even now the repairs just completed only bring it back up to Cat 3 standards.

Reply to this comment
Posted by  
on June 1, 2006, 2:02 pm
If they only built it back to Cat 3 speed then the next time a Cat 5 comes along and does it again then thats Louisiana's fault, because they should have put in for the funding to build it stronger since they know what will happen to it. Another thing is when they say Hurricane Warning GET OUT!! DON'T STAY AND WAIT FOR SOMEONE TO HAVE TO RESCUE YOU!! That's what the problem was. Another I would'nt try to rescue anyone that is trying to shoot at me, I would leave too.

Reply to this comment